Reviews

• Comfortably Posh

  Submitted on: 04/12/2009

  The caley is an old victorian hotel which has been updated without losing the charm. the staff was friendly and welcoming. this a truly a 5 start hotel but it ...

  The Caley is an old Victorian hotel which has been updated without losing the charm. The staff was friendly and welcoming. This a truly a 5 start hotel but it is comfortable and not pretentious. Location is just below Edinburgh Castle. The Castle is a healthy but not insurmountable walk from the hotel. Breakfast is amazing. Two rooms of food from which to select plus the ability to order eggs, french toast and other breakfast goodies. We took advantage of their prepaid B&B offer. I thought we'd get a tiny room on the 5th floor. Instead we got a lovely very large room on the 3rd floor. View was overlooking the car park but it got lots of sun and the windows opened. Only suggestion would be for the hotel to find a way to install a bathroom night light. We would stay here again, especially if they offered their B&B program.

  • Room Quality
  • Bed Comfort
  • Staff And Service
  • Cleanliness
  • Value For Money
  • Security Safety
  • Location
  +Click to Show Review
  -Click to Hide Review
• Hilton Caledonian

  Submitted on: 06/20/2007

  This is a beautiful hotel. we had slight issues in that the hair dryer and television didn't work, but other than that, the stay was great. the hotel is ...

  This is a beautiful hotel. We had slight issues in that the hair dryer and television didn't work, but other than that, the stay was great. The hotel is beautiful and has a great view of the castle.

  • Room Quality
  • Staff And Service
  • Dining
  +Click to Show Review
  -Click to Hide Review
• Great location/Bad staff

  Submitted on: 06/13/2007

  Location was excellent, hotel is beautiful (floorplan a bit eccentric). close to edinburgh castle and princes' street. staff was not helpful, not welcoming, did nothing extra to warrant me staying ...

  Location was excellent, hotel is beautiful (floorplan a bit eccentric). Close to Edinburgh Castle and Princes' street. Staff was not helpful, not welcoming, did nothing extra to warrant me staying at their hotel again

  • Room Quality
  • Staff And Service
  • Dining
  • Activities
  +Click to Show Review
  -Click to Hide Review

• 1 - 3